Is your supermarket olive oil really extra virgin? The truth about blends.

Your olive oil is probably a blend. What kind of blend makes the difference.

Here's something the olive oil industry would prefer you didn't think too hard about: most extra virgin olive oil is blended. Not just the cheap stuff. The good stuff too.

Blending itself isn't the problem. Winemakers blend grapes. Cheesemakers blend milks.  Blending different olive varieties from the same orchard is actually an ancient, intentional craft. For practical purposes, growing different trees together increased their survival in the event of a drought or virus that could affect certain but not all cultivars. Different cultivars also contribute different flavors, and together they make something more complex than any one variety alone. 

The problem is a different kind of blending entirely.

What's actually in most supermarket olive oil?

Flip over almost any bottle from a major brand and look for the origin statement. You'll usually find something like: "Product of the following countries [XYZ]" or "Product of Italy, Greece, Spain, and/or Tunisia".

That "and/or" is doing a lot of work. It means the contents of the bottle may vary batch to batch, blended from whatever is cheapest and most available on the commodity market that season. Large producers buy olive oil in bulk from multiple countries, blend it for a consistent color and flavor profile, and bottle it under a label that sounds Italian.

The goal is price and shelf stability. Not flavor. Not health benefits.

What a "single-origin blend" actually means

Pegaso is proud of its blends. Starting with its original Family Blend N.1, every olive in the bottle comes from the same 800 tree-orchard on the same hillside in southeastern Sicily. Three cultivars (Biancolilla, Nocellara Messinese and Tonda Iblea) have grown side by side, harvested together and pressed together for generations.

Each variety contributes something distinct:

• Biancolilla: delicate, slightly fruity — gives the oil its lightness and approachability
  
• Nocellara Messinese: body and a clean grassy note — the backbone of the blend
  
• Tonda Iblea: peppery finish — the warmth at the back of your throat that signals high polyphenols and an early harvest

This is what blending was meant to be: not a cost-cutting exercise, but a craft decision made by people who know their land and trees intimately. Our family has been making this same blend since 1916. It's the same olive oil you'll find on our kitchen counter. 

How to tell the difference when you're shopping

Three things to look for before you buy:

1. A specific region of origin, not just a country.
"Product of Italy" tells you almost nothing. It can be a blend from three countries packaged in Italy. You want to see one specific region. Even better if it names the farm, estate, zone or cultivar(s). "From southeastern Sicily" or "From Mt. Iblei, Sicily" tells you something. 

2. A harvest date, not just an expiration date.
Good olive oil is perishable. You want to know when it was made. Most commodity oils don't include one because the answer wouldn't be flattering. Especially when there are different harvests in one bottle.

3. And smell it. Taste it. 
A real extra virgin olive oil should be grassy, peppery and slightly bitter. If it smells and tastes like nothing (smooth and neutral), that's not a good thing. That's a sign of what's missing. Most likely it's a blend of different low quality harvests or even a blend with another type of vegetable oil. 

We'd love for you to taste the difference yourself. 

Shop Pegaso EVOO →